The Best Smash Burger in Indianapolis

 

The Legend of "Workingman’s Friend":  Indy’s Smash Burger Icon

Origins & Atmosphere

Workingman’s Friend (originally Belmont Lunch) opened in 1918, founded by Louis “Louie” Stamatkin, a Macedonian immigrant. His small lunch counter catered largely to railroad workers and locals in the Belmont/Brookside area. 

Over the decades, it stayed in the same family. Today, Becky Stamatkin, Louie’s granddaughter, runs the place. 

The place has a no-frills, old school dive feel: cash only, worn-in booths, glass block windows, a classic grill, nostalgic charm. It’s not trying to be trendy—it is the trend. 

What Makes Their Smash Burger Special

• Technique: They form fresh ground chuck into balls, then cook them on a hot flat-top grill. Once they hit the griddle, they “smash” the patty down with a spatula. That creates a thin, crispy, edged crust—lacy, crunchy edges with rich browning (the Maillard reaction) balanced against juicier interior bits. 

• Simplicity: No over-the-top toppings. Typically, cheeseburger style with onion, maybe some classic condiments. The burger IS the thing. 

• Value & Character: The price is very reasonable (classic burgers under $10 in many cases), but more than that, people come for the vibe: historic, local, authentic. 

Accolades & Local Reputation

Workingman’s Friend has been repeatedly named the best burger in Indiana in various outlets:

• Thrillist and other “best burger in the state” type lists. 

• Food & Wine also praised it. 

• In “Taste Test: Indy’s Smashburger Boom” (May 2025), it’s included among the very top smash burger spots in the city. 

• Holdup a Minute !

Workingman’s Friend is iconic, but Indy has more than one strong smash. Here are several contenders, each with its own twist.

	Smash'd Burger Bar (Irvington) Classic Midwestern beef cheeseburger, plus creative monthly specials. Great atmosphere, waffle fries, consistent quality. Their claim: “best smashed burgers  in Indy” 10 Johnson Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46219 (317) 419-2894 Daredevil Hall They mix up premium meat blends (chuck + short rib + brisket), sometimes fancy toppings (avocado, bacon, even peanut butter). Broad menu, nice space. Great for when you want a splash‐up version of a smash.  2721 E 86th St Ste 180 Indianapolis, IN 46240 (317) 757-2888 Natural State Provision  Southern-inspired, relaxed bar/dive feel, solid classic smash with option for double, plus good sides. Ideal if you want something a bit more modern but still faithful to the smash style. 414 Dorman St Indianapolis, IN 46202 (317) 492-9887 One Trick Pony  Known for their “Old John” Diner-Style Burger, customizable toppings, multiple patties if you want more. Also, local touches like using regional producers. 9713 District N Dr Ste 1210 Fishers, IN 46037 (317) 953-6398 x 104
	BJ