The Legend of "Workingman’s Friend": Indy’s Smash Burger Icon
Origins & Atmosphere
Workingman’s Friend (originally Belmont Lunch) opened in 1918, founded by Louis “Louie” Stamatkin, a Macedonian immigrant. His small lunch counter catered largely to railroad workers and locals in the Belmont/Brookside area.
Over the decades, it stayed in the same family. Today, Becky Stamatkin, Louie’s granddaughter, runs the place.
The place has a no-frills, old school dive feel: cash only, worn-in booths, glass block windows, a classic grill, nostalgic charm. It’s not trying to be trendy—it is the trend.
What Makes Their Smash Burger Special
-
Technique: They form fresh ground chuck into balls, then cook them on a hot flat-top grill. Once they hit the griddle, they “smash” the patty down with a spatula. That creates a thin, crispy, edged crust—lacy, crunchy edges with rich browning (the Maillard reaction) balanced against juicier interior bits.
-
Simplicity: No over-the-top toppings. Typically, cheeseburger style with onion, maybe some classic condiments. The burger IS the thing.
-
Value & Character: The price is very reasonable (classic burgers under $10 in many cases), but more than that, people come for the vibe: historic, local, authentic.
Accolades & Local Reputation
Workingman’s Friend has been repeatedly named the best burger in Indiana in various outlets:
-
Thrillist and other “best burger in the state” type lists.
-
Food & Wine also praised it.
-
In “Taste Test: Indy’s Smashburger Boom” (May 2025), it’s included among the very top smash burger spots in the city.
Holdup a Minute !
Workingman’s Friend is iconic, but Indy has more than one strong smash. Here are several contenders, each with its own twist.
| Smash'd Burger Bar (Irvington) Classic Midwestern beef cheeseburger, plus creative monthly specials. Great atmosphere, waffle fries, consistent quality. Their claim: “best smashed burgers in Indy” 10 Johnson Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46219 (317) 419-2894 Daredevil Hall They mix up premium meat blends (chuck + short rib + brisket), sometimes fancy toppings (avocado, bacon, even peanut butter). Broad menu, nice space. Great for when you want a splash‐up version of a smash. 2721 E 86th St Ste 180 Indianapolis, IN 46240 (317) 757-2888 Natural State Provision Southern-inspired, relaxed bar/dive feel, solid classic smash with option for double, plus good sides. Ideal if you want something a bit more modern but still faithful to the smash style. 414 Dorman St Indianapolis, IN 46202 (317) 492-9887 One Trick Pony Known for their “Old John” Diner-Style Burger, customizable toppings, multiple patties if you want more. Also, local touches like using regional producers. 9713 District N Dr Ste 1210 Fishers, IN 46037 (317) 953-6398 x 104 | |
|---|---|
| BJ | |